Ahead by
The difference in total wealth between the two paths at the end of your stay, before income taxes. A small gap means the choice depends more on preferences than on money.
Compare buying a home with renting a similar one. The calculator tracks every month you plan to stay, invests whatever the cheaper option saves, and shows which leaves you with more money and when buying breaks even.
The starting figures describe a hypothetical $400,000 home and a $2,300 rental. The mortgage rate is Freddie Mac's 30-year average of 7.40% for October 15, 2026; use the rate you are quoted.
Formula: Buying wealth = home value × (1 − selling costs) − loan balance + invested savings. Renting wealth = down payment and closing costs invested + invested savings. Each month, whichever option costs less invests the difference.
Monthly cost to own is mortgage principal and interest, property tax, maintenance, insurance and HOA dues. Income taxes are left out. Starting figures are hypothetical examples, except where a section names its source. Results are screening estimates, not appraisals, loan approvals or investment advice.
It compares two households with the same starting cash. One buys; the other rents and invests the down payment and closing costs. Here is the default example.
Buying the $400,000 home takes an $80,000 down payment and $12,000 of closing costs. The renter invests that $92,000 instead at 5% a year.
A $320,000, 30-year loan at 7.40% costs $2,216 a month. Add property tax, maintenance and insurance and owning costs about $3,066 a month, against $2,300 rent. The renter invests the $766 difference each month.
The home gains 3% a year and rent rises 3% a year. Both savings pots earn 5% a year. Owner costs tied to home value rise with it.
After 7 years the home is worth about $491,950. After 6% selling costs and the $293,441 loan balance, the buyer has $168,992. The renter's portfolio is $192,863, so renting is ahead by $23,872.
With these inputs buying first comes out ahead at the end of year 12. After 30 years the buyer is ahead by about $435,000.
The break-even year moves a lot with the mortgage rate, price growth and how long you stay. Rerun the calculator with a lower rate or a longer stay and watch the result change.
The difference in total wealth between the two paths at the end of your stay, before income taxes. A small gap means the choice depends more on preferences than on money.
The first year-end when selling the home would leave you with more than renting and investing. Staying fewer years than this favors renting.
For a quick market screen, divide the home price by a year of rent. $400,000 ÷ ($2,300 × 12) = 14.5. Our price-to-rent ratio guide explains how to read it.
Income tax effects, mortgage insurance, moving costs and renters insurance. A home sale gain may also be partly tax-free under the IRS home sale exclusion; see our capital gains calculator.
QUICK ANSWERS
It depends on how long you stay, the mortgage rate, home price growth and rent. With this page's default figures and a 7.40% rate, renting is ahead after 7 years and buying pulls ahead in year 12. Enter your own numbers to see your answer.
Money not spent on housing would usually be saved. Investing it at the same return for both households makes the comparison fair: the renter keeps the down payment working, and the buyer invests whenever owning costs less than renting.
Use a return you would realistically expect on money you would otherwise put into a down payment. A higher return favors renting; a lower one favors buying. The 5% default is a placeholder, not a forecast.
No. Income taxes are left out for both paths. If you take the standard deduction instead of itemizing, mortgage interest does not lower your federal tax. A tax professional can tell you which applies to you.
Long enough to recover buying and selling costs through equity and price growth. The break-even year shows that point for your inputs.
Sources reviewed October 19, 2026. The mortgage rate is Freddie Mac's published weekly average; all other starting figures are hypothetical.